Vygotsky:
Vygotsky says that through play, a child will develop an abstract meaning that is separate from objects in the world. He says that this is a critical feature in the development of higher mental functions. One of his most famous examples is a child wanting to ride a horse, but they can’t. If the child is younger than three years old, they will most likely throw a tantrum. But, if the child is three years old or older, they will most likely pick up a stick and ride it around, pretending that it is a horse. Vygotsky also says that the rules of behavior that go unnoticed in daily life are consciously acquired through play. The child will ignore what their impulse is trying to tell them because of the rules of whatever they are playing.
Piaget:
Piaget believes that play is almost pure assimilation without any attempt to adapt to outer reality. His famous example is a child playing with a block. When a child is playing “airplane” with a block, he/she is unconcerned about what the airplane needs to look like to defy gravity or overcome air pressure. The child is just playing with the blocks, imitating what he/she has seen. However, if a house burned down in the area where a preschool was, then if the child was playing with the blocks, their house might “catch fire.” They would pretend to be firemen, saving the people in the house. Piaget says that as they do this, they are making a serious attempt to accommodate the reality of what they have seen or heard.
Piaget believes that play is almost pure assimilation without any attempt to adapt to outer reality. His famous example is a child playing with a block. When a child is playing “airplane” with a block, he/she is unconcerned about what the airplane needs to look like to defy gravity or overcome air pressure. The child is just playing with the blocks, imitating what he/she has seen. However, if a house burned down in the area where a preschool was, then if the child was playing with the blocks, their house might “catch fire.” They would pretend to be firemen, saving the people in the house. Piaget says that as they do this, they are making a serious attempt to accommodate the reality of what they have seen or heard.
Erikson:
Erikson believed that play is very important in the early stages of a child’s development. He says it offers a safe place for a child to go when there are conflicts in the child’s life. He also says that play is a safe world where the consequences are not strong at all and the limits are not rigid. The child can be the authoritarian – the one stopping things, not the one being stopped. The last thing he said was that play affords the exploration and manipulation of ideas and relationships without too much shame, guilt, and doubt.
I think Erikson’s theory is most correct. When a little kid is playing by themselves, they don’t really know what is going on in the world around them. They are in their own world, and they feel protected for what is going on in their life. These three theories do not really contradict each other. They have their differences, but they also have their similarities. These theories can work together to help people understand social development in children more thoroughly, but only parts of social development. These theories only cover the play part of social development, not every other aspect of it.